Slumbra

White vs pink vs brown noise: which is best for sleep?

By Slumbra · Updated · 2 min read

What is the difference between white, pink and brown noise?

The "colors" describe how the sound's energy is spread across frequencies:

  • White noise: equal energy at every frequency. Because our ears are more sensitive to high frequencies, it sounds bright, like TV static or an air vent.
  • Pink noise: energy halves each time the frequency doubles, so it has more bass than white noise. It sounds softer, like steady rain or surf.
  • Brown noise (also red or Brownian noise): even more bass and less treble. It sounds deep, like a waterfall, strong wind or an airplane cabin.

None is better than the others; they simply sound different.

Does noise actually help you sleep?

The clearest effect is masking. What wakes people is usually not how loud a sound is but how much it stands out from the background. Steady background noise narrows that gap, so a passing car or a closing door is less likely to wake you.

Whether playing noise all night makes sleep better is less certain. A 2021 systematic review by Riedy and colleagues in Sleep Medicine Reviews concluded that the evidence is of low quality and that more rigorous studies are needed.

Does pink noise increase deep sleep?

This claim comes from research on sound stimulation during slow-wave sleep. In a 2013 study in Neuron, Ngo and colleagues used EEG to detect slow waves in real time and played short bursts of pink noise at a precise point in each wave; slow waves became stronger and memory the next day improved. Papalambros and colleagues found similar results in older adults in 2017.

Two caveats: those studies played short sounds timed to brain waves, not background noise all night, and they needed an EEG, which a phone cannot do. So "pink noise all night increases deep sleep" has not been shown.

How do I choose the right one?

  1. Let your ears decide: listen to each for a minute or two and pick the least intrusive. Most people find pink or brown noise more pleasant than white.
  2. Match your environment: brown noise masks low rumbling traffic better; pink or white noise masks voices and higher-pitched sounds better.
  3. Compare over several nights: one night tells you little. Note how long it took to fall asleep and how often you woke up, then decide.

How loud is safe?

As quiet as works: just enough to cover the background, and no louder than soft speech. Keep the phone or speaker at least a meter from your head, avoid headphones all night, and use a fade-out or sleep timer.

FAQ

Is white or pink noise better for sleep?

It depends on the person. Pink noise has more bass and sounds softer, so many people prefer it, but the best one is whichever sounds most relaxing to you and covers the noise around you.

Is it harmful to play white noise all night?

At a moderate volume there is no evidence of harm. Keep it below the level of soft speech, keep the speaker away from your head, or let it fade out once you are asleep.

Can babies listen to white noise?

Yes, at a low volume and with the device placed well away from the crib, never in or right next to it. Ask a pediatrician if you have concerns.

Sources

  1. Riedy SM, Smith MG, Rocha S, Basner M. Noise as a sleep aid: A systematic review. Sleep Med Rev. 2021;55:101385.
  2. Ngo HV, Martinetz T, Born J, Mölle M. Auditory closed-loop stimulation of the sleep slow oscillation enhances memory. Neuron. 2013;78(3):545–553.
  3. Papalambros NA, et al. Acoustic Enhancement of Sleep Slow Oscillations and Concomitant Memory Improvement in Older Adults. Front Hum Neurosci. 2017;11:109.

Slumbra is not a medical device. Content on this site is general information and does not replace diagnosis or treatment by a doctor.

Related

All articles →